Select Your Cake Size

6″ (serves 6 to 8) : $35
8″ (serves 10 to 12) : $55
10″ (serves 15 to 20) : $83

NOTE: If you choose a cake listed below with (**) designation, prices will be as follows:
**6″ (serves 6 to 8) : $30
**8″ (serves 10 to 12) : $50
**10″ (serves 15 to 20) : $68

Customize your Cake

Choose from a selection of Cafe FiftyFour cake flavours for your next special occasion!
Available filling options are listed below each cake type. No substitutions.

Chocolate Cake

Sprinkle (Classic Buttercream)**
Nutella Buttercream
Peanut Butter Buttercream
Tiramisu Buttercream
Dark Chocolate Ganache
Earl Grey Ganache

Vanilla Cake

Sprinkle (Classic Buttercream)**
Seasonal Berry Buttercream
Lemon Buttercream
Tiramisu Buttercream

Red Velvet Cake

Cream Cheese Frosting
Vanilla Buttercream
Dark Chocolate Ganache

Seasonal Feature Cake

Pumpkin Spice Cake
Layers of pumpkin cake and spiced cream cheese frosting, topped in caramel drip and candied pumpkin seeds.
6″ $42.00
8″ $65.00

Chiffon Cake

All Chiffon cakes are layered with the following curds or creams and covered with toasted Swiss meringue.
Vanilla Raspberry

Carrot Cake **

Cream Cheese Frosting


Add Florals : $15
Add Golf Leaf: $10
Add Macarons: $2.75 each or 3 for $6.50

We require a minimum of 24 hours notice for any cake style listed above.
Any custom orders placed require a minimum of 72 hours to 2 weeks notice depending on style, design and size. If you have any questions please reach out to our team at sales@cafefiftyfour.com 

Scroll to Top